The episode is available for streaming on several platforms:
Cynthia and Antwon Mans are shown grappling with the strain of having Natalia in their home. While they initially defended her, in this episode, they express frustration:
The final ten minutes of “The Return” feature explosive, low-fidelity audio. Bishop Antwon reveals that he installed a voice-activated recorder in the guest bedroom where Natalia stays (legal in New York, as it is his home and he is a party to the conversation). The Curious Case of Natalia Grace S03E02 The Re...
Unlike the previous seasons that relied on Michael Barnett’s theatrical monologues or Natalia’s shocking interviews, Episode 2 opens with a quiet, almost clinical title card: "Fishers, Indiana – Present Day."
In 2019, Michael and Kristine Barnett filed a $6 million lawsuit against Natalia, alleging that she threatened to kill them. Natalia countered with her own allegations of abuse. The case drew significant media attention due to its bizarre allegations and the division between supporters of Natalia and those who believe the Barnetts. The episode is available for streaming on several
Natalia's care required specific medical, legal, and financial resources that put an immediate strain on the DePauls.
," originally premiered on January 5, 2025, as part of the four-part finale season, The Final Chapter Unlike the previous seasons that relied on Michael
Yes. While most viewers remember the Barnetts being charged with neglect (they were eventually acquitted of most charges), there was a quiet investigation into whether Natalia had been the aggressor in certain incidents. Specifically, a 2012 incident involving a neighbor’s toddler.