La version longue ne fait pas qu'ajouter du temps ; elle comble des lacunes narratives qui rendent la version cinéma parfois abrupte, en particulier concernant le destin de certains personnages. Cohérence narrative :

This scene elevates the tension dramatically. By presenting evidence of Frodo’s capture, the Mouth convinces the Captains of the West that their quest has failed. This heightens the stakes significantly—we see the despair on the faces of Gandalf and Aragorn. It creates a moment of false defeat that makes the subsequent victory feel even more miraculous. It also serves as a chilling visual representation of Sauron’s cruelty, bridging the gap between the abstract villain and his tangible servants.

So if you want the → Version longue is absolutely top. If you want the tightest, most award-savvy cut → Theatrical is still excellent.